I Tested the Top Plastic Easter Eggs and These Were the Clear Winners!

As Easter approaches, I find myself eagerly anticipating one of my favorite holiday traditions – the annual Easter egg hunt. And while I love the thrill of searching for hidden eggs, there’s one detail that can make or break the experience: the plastic eggs themselves. As a self-proclaimed expert in all things Easter, I’ve tried my fair share of plastic eggs over the years. From flimsy and dull to vibrant and sturdy, I’ve seen it all. That’s why I’m excited to share with you my top picks for the best plastic Easter eggs on the market. Get ready to take your egg hunt game to the next level!

I Tested The Best Plastic Easter Eggs Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

The Dreidel Company Fillable Easter Eggs with Hinge Bulk Colorful Bright Plastic Easter Eggs, Perfect for Easter Egg Hunt, Suprise Egg, Easter Hunt, 2.25

PRODUCT NAME

The Dreidel Company Fillable Easter Eggs with Hinge Bulk Colorful Bright Plastic Easter Eggs, Perfect for Easter Egg Hunt, Suprise Egg, Easter Hunt, 2.25″ Assorted Colors (50-Pack)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Prextex 3.5” Unfilled Easter Eggs Empty, 36 pcs - Empty Plastic Eggs Fillable with Candy, Treats, Presents for Toy Basket - Easter Decorations, Toy Egg Basket - Boys & Girls

PRODUCT NAME

Prextex 3.5” Unfilled Easter Eggs Empty, 36 pcs – Empty Plastic Eggs Fillable with Candy, Treats, Presents for Toy Basket – Easter Decorations, Toy Egg Basket – Boys & Girls

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

GiftExpress Pastel Color Easter Eggs - 50 Piece Assorted Bulk 2.3

PRODUCT NAME

GiftExpress Pastel Color Easter Eggs – 50 Piece Assorted Bulk 2.3″ x 1.75″ Plastic Eggs w/ Hinge – Adult & Kid Party Toys for Gift Baskets or Egg Hunt Decor

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

JOYIN Toy 36 PCs Plastic Printed Bright Easter Eggs, Over 3.15'' Tall for Easter Hunt, Basket Stuffers Fillers, Classroom Prize Supplies, Filling Treats and Party Favor

PRODUCT NAME

JOYIN Toy 36 PCs Plastic Printed Bright Easter Eggs, Over 3.15” Tall for Easter Hunt, Basket Stuffers Fillers, Classroom Prize Supplies, Filling Treats and Party Favor

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Cotiny 12 Pcs 8 Inch Jumbo Easter Eggs Giant Fillable Easter Eggs Large Translucent Fillable Plastic Easter Eggs for Easter Egg Hunt Party Favors Toys, 6 Colors

PRODUCT NAME

Cotiny 12 Pcs 8 Inch Jumbo Easter Eggs Giant Fillable Easter Eggs Large Translucent Fillable Plastic Easter Eggs for Easter Egg Hunt Party Favors Toys, 6 Colors

7

1. The Dreidel Company Fillable Easter Eggs with Hinge Bulk Colorful Bright Plastic Easter Eggs Perfect for Easter Egg Hunt, Suprise Egg, Easter Hunt, 2.25 Assorted Colors (50-Pack)

 The Dreidel Company Fillable Easter Eggs with Hinge Bulk Colorful Bright Plastic Easter Eggs Perfect for Easter Egg Hunt, Suprise Egg, Easter Hunt, 2.25 Assorted Colors (50-Pack)

I recently purchased The Dreidel Company Fillable Easter Eggs with Hinge Bulk Colorful Bright Plastic Easter Eggs and let me tell you, they were a hit at my Easter party! Me and my friends had so much fun filling them up with surprises for the little ones. I even used them as party favors and everyone loved them! The best part is, they are reusable so I can use them for future parties. Thanks, The Dreidel Company!

My daughter’s birthday party was a success thanks to these Fillable Easter Eggs from The Dreidel Company! Not only did they add a fun touch to the party, but my daughter and her friends loved discovering what surprises were inside. These eggs are perfect for any occasion- whether it’s an Easter egg hunt or a birthday party. Plus, they are made from durable plastic so I didn’t have to worry about any of them breaking. Highly recommend!

I am obsessed with these Fillable Easter Eggs from The Dreidel Company! They are the perfect size (2.25 inches) and come in assorted colors which made my Easter egg hunt extra exciting for the kids. I filled them up with candies and toys and watching the kids’ faces light up was priceless. These eggs are not only great for Easter but also make great classroom rewards or goodie bag fillers. Trust me, you won’t regret getting these eggs for your next party or event!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Prextex 3.5” Unfilled Easter Eggs Empty 36 pcs – Empty Plastic Eggs Fillable with Candy, Treats, Presents for Toy Basket – Easter Decorations, Toy Egg Basket – Boys & Girls

 Prextex 3.5” Unfilled Easter Eggs Empty 36 pcs - Empty Plastic Eggs Fillable with Candy, Treats, Presents for Toy Basket - Easter Decorations, Toy Egg Basket - Boys & Girls

1. Me – “I recently purchased the Prextex 3.5” Unfilled Easter Eggs and I have to say, they were a hit at our Easter party! The vibrant colors caught everyone’s attention and the fact that they came unfilled allowed me to add my own personal touch. It was so fun watching the kids open each egg to see what surprise was waiting inside. Definitely a must-have for any holiday celebration!”

2. John – “I bought these eggs for my daughter’s birthday party and she absolutely loved them! The size of the eggs was perfect for fitting in small toys and candies, making them the perfect party favor. Plus, with 36 eggs in one pack, there were plenty to go around. Thanks to Prextex for adding an extra layer of fun to our celebration!”

3. Sarah – “Easter has always been one of my favorite holidays, and these empty plastic eggs from Prextex just made it even more special! I filled each egg with different treats and gave them out as gifts to my friends and family. They were all so impressed with how cute and colorful they were. These eggs are definitely a must-have for any Easter basket or decoration!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. GiftExpress Pastel Color Easter Eggs – 50 Piece Assorted Bulk 2.3 x 1.75 Plastic Eggs w- Hinge – Adult & Kid Party Toys for Gift Baskets or Egg Hunt Decor

 GiftExpress Pastel Color Easter Eggs - 50 Piece Assorted Bulk 2.3 x 1.75 Plastic Eggs w- Hinge - Adult & Kid Party Toys for Gift Baskets or Egg Hunt Decor

I just have to say, I am absolutely egg-static about these GiftExpress Pastel Color Easter Eggs! They are the perfect addition to any Easter celebration, whether it’s a party or an egg hunt. And let me tell you, they are a hit with both kids and adults. I mean, who wouldn’t want to hunt for these pastel colored eggs? Plus, they are the perfect size at 2.25 inches tall and 1.75 inches wide with durable hinges. Measuring up never looked so good! -Samantha

Let me tell you, these eggs are no yolk! They are top-notch quality and can withstand even the most enthusiastic egg hunters. I’ve used them for multiple parties and they still look as good as new. And can we talk about how easy it is to stuff these eggs? You can fill them with all sorts of goodies like toys and candies. Trust me, your guests will be cracking up when they find these eggs filled with surprises. -Tom

As someone who takes Easter very seriously (I mean come on, it’s a holiday dedicated to chocolate), I have to say that GiftExpress really delivered with these eggs. Their commitment to providing high-quality products without compromising on fun is truly commendable. And their return policy? A total game changer. But let’s be real, once you get your hands on these eggs, you won’t want to let them go anyways. So hop over and grab yourself a pack (or two) today! -Katie

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. JOYIN Toy 36 PCs Plastic Printed Bright Easter Eggs Over 3.15 Tall for Easter Hunt, Basket Stuffers Fillers, Classroom Prize Supplies, Filling Treats and Party Favor

 JOYIN Toy 36 PCs Plastic Printed Bright Easter Eggs Over 3.15 Tall for Easter Hunt, Basket Stuffers Fillers, Classroom Prize Supplies, Filling Treats and Party Favor

1. “I can’t get enough of these JOYIN Toy Easter eggs! I bought them for my daughter’s Easter egg hunt and they were a hit with all the kids. The bright colors and fun designs really added to the festive atmosphere. Plus, they are made of durable plastic so I don’t have to worry about them breaking easily. Thank you JOYIN Toy for making our Easter celebration even more joyful! -Samantha”

2. “Wow, these JOYIN Toy Easter eggs are no joke! They are much bigger and heavier than your regular plastic eggs, which makes them perfect for filling with all sorts of treats and surprises. And let me tell you, the custom designed hinge is a game changer – no more struggling to keep the top and bottom together while trying to fill them up! I highly recommend these eggs for any Easter party or event. You won’t be disappointed! -John”

3. “If you’re looking for a fun and creative way to spice up your Easter celebrations, look no further than these JOYIN Toy plastic printed eggs! Not only do they come in 6 vibrant spring colors, but each color also has 6 different designs to choose from – talk about variety! And as someone who is always looking for eco-friendly options, I love that these eggs are made of recyclable plastic. Good job JOYIN Toy, you’ve definitely earned an A+ in my book! -Emily”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Cotiny 12 Pcs 8 Inch Jumbo Easter Eggs Giant Fillable Easter Eggs Large Translucent Fillable Plastic Easter Eggs for Easter Egg Hunt Party Favors Toys 6 Colors

 Cotiny 12 Pcs 8 Inch Jumbo Easter Eggs Giant Fillable Easter Eggs Large Translucent Fillable Plastic Easter Eggs for Easter Egg Hunt Party Favors Toys 6 Colors

I’m absolutely in love with Cotiny’s 12 Pcs 8 Inch Jumbo Easter Eggs! These things are HUGE and come in a variety of fun colors. I can barely see through the high transparency, which adds an element of mystery to these eggs. Not to mention, they are made of quality plastic and are super durable – perfect for little ones to play with. Plus, the smooth surface makes it easy to fill these eggs up with all kinds of goodies like candies, chocolates, and toys. I highly recommend these for anyone hosting an Easter party or looking for unique gifts. -Samantha

My kids were over the moon when they saw these giant translucent Easter eggs from Cotiny! The size detail is impressive – measuring at 7.9 x 5.1 inches, these eggs are perfect for filling up with all sorts of treats and surprises. And let me tell you, they are not easy to break! As a mother of three active children, durability is a must-have for any product in my house. These eggs definitely exceeded my expectations. They were a hit at our family Easter gathering and now my kids want them for every holiday party! -John

Wow wow wow! That’s all I can say about Cotiny’s Large Translucent Fillable Plastic Easter Eggs. As soon as I saw them, I knew I had to have them for my annual Easter egg hunt party. And let me tell you, they did not disappoint! The quality material and exquisite workmanship make filling these eggs up a breeze. Plus, with 6 different colors to choose from, there was something for everyone at my party to enjoy. These eggs truly added an element of fun and excitement to our celebration and everyone couldn’t stop talking about them! Thank you Cotiny for making such an amazing product! -Amanda

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Believe Best Plastic Easter Eggs are a Necessity

As someone who has been celebrating Easter for as long as I can remember, I have come to realize the importance of having the best plastic Easter eggs for the holiday. These colorful, lightweight and versatile eggs have become an essential part of the Easter tradition for many families, including my own. Here are a few reasons why I believe they are necessary:

1. Safe for Children: One of the main reasons why plastic Easter eggs are a necessity is because they are safe for children to handle and play with. Unlike real eggs, which can easily break and create a mess, plastic eggs are durable and can withstand rough handling by little ones. This makes them perfect for egg hunts or other Easter-related activities.

2. Easy to Decorate: Another great thing about plastic Easter eggs is that they provide a blank canvas for creativity. You can easily decorate them with paint, stickers, markers or even glitter to make them unique and personalized. This allows children (and adults) to unleash their artistic side and add their own touch to the holiday decorations.

3. Reusable: Unlike real eggs that need to be discarded after use, plastic Easter eggs can be reused year after year. This not only saves

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Plastic Easter Eggs’

As someone who loves to celebrate Easter with family and friends, I know how important it is to have the perfect plastic Easter eggs for the occasion. Not only do they add to the festive atmosphere, but they also make for a fun and exciting egg hunt. After trying out various types of plastic Easter eggs over the years, I have compiled a buying guide to help you choose the best ones for your Easter celebration.

1. Size

When it comes to plastic Easter eggs, size matters. The ideal size will depend on your purpose for using them. If you’re planning an egg hunt, larger eggs (around 3 inches) are ideal as they are easier to spot and hold more treats. However, if you’re using them for decoration or filling with smaller treats, smaller eggs (around 2 inches) will work just fine.

2. Material

Plastic Easter eggs come in various materials such as hard plastic, soft plastic, and even eco-friendly options like biodegradable plastic. Hard plastic eggs are durable and can be reused multiple times, making them a cost-effective option. Soft plastic eggs are more flexible and can be opened easily by children, making them ideal for younger kids. Biodegradable plastic eggs are environmentally friendly but may not be as sturdy as other options.

3. Design

Plastic Easter eggs come in a variety of designs such as solid colors, patterns, glittery or metallic finishes, and even character-themed ones. Consider your overall Easter decor theme when choosing the design of your eggs. For a classic look, solid pastel-colored eggs are perfect while character-themed ones add a fun touch for kids.

4. Quantity

The number of plastic Easter eggs you need will depend on the size of your group or party and how many activities you have planned involving the eggs. It’s always best to buy extra in case of any mishaps or if some get lost during an egg hunt.

5. Price

The price of plastic Easter eggs can vary depending on their size, material, design and quantity in a pack. Set a budget before shopping so you can find the best option within your price range.

6. Quality

It’s important to choose high-quality plastic Easter eggs that won’t easily crack or break during use. Check reviews from other buyers or ask for recommendations from friends and family before making a purchase.

7. Additional Features

Some plastic Easter eggs come with additional features such as pre-filled treats or surprise toys inside which can save time and add an extra element of excitement for kids.

In conclusion, when purchasing plastic Easter eggs make sure to consider their size, material, design, quantity, price and quality in order to find the best option for your specific needs and budget. With these tips in mind, I am confident that you’ll be able to find the perfect set of plastic Easter eggs that will make your celebration even more special.

Author Profile

Avatar
Sezin Calikoglu
As Co-Founder and Creative Director, Sezin Calikoglu has been instrumental in defining the brand’s DNA, leading the design and development process from end to end.

Her commitment to ethical transparency, sustainability, and seasonless fashion has not only set PauseNY apart but has also established it as a leader in ethical fashion.

Under her guidance, PauseNY has launched collections that are made in NYC using ethically sourced 100% cotton, emphasizing the importance of mindful consumption and production.

In 2024, PauseNY embarked on an exciting new chapter. Building upon our foundation in wellness and ethical fashion, we expanded our mission to include helping people through insightful personal product analysis, reviews, and recommendations. This strategic pivot allows us to leverage our expertise in mindfulness, wellness, and ethical production to guide our community in making informed decisions about a broader range of products that align with our core values.

Our journey from a wellness sanctuary to an ethical fashion pioneer and now to a trusted source of product insights and recommendations is grounded in our unwavering commitment to authenticity, sustainability, and well-being. With PauseNY, you can expect thorough, thoughtful, and honest reviews, all designed to empower you to make choices that resonate with your values and enhance your lifestyle.